SeatLab HQ LogoSeatLabHQ.com

Fractal Design Refine vs Herman Miller Sayl

A detailed side-by-side comparison scored on 11 objective criteria.

FD

Fractal Design Refine

Ergonomic Office
23.5/55
$550-$600
WINNER
HMHerman Miller Sayl

Herman Miller Sayl

Ergonomic Office
27/55
$600-$900
Criteria
Fractal Design Refine
Herman Miller Sayl
Total Score23.5/5527/55
Price Rating3/53/5
Seat Depth Adjustability2/52/5
Height Range3/53/5
Lumbar Comfort1/52/5*
Armrests2/52/5
Upper Back Support2/52/5
Neck Support2/5*0/5
Breathability2/54/5*
Material Quality2/52.5/5*
Softness1/51.5/5*
Warranty3.5/55/5*
Pros
  • +4D armrests with 15° rotation
  • +Adjustable lumbar support (height + depth)
  • +Memory foam headrest with 120mm adjustment
  • +11 lockable recline positions up to 125°
  • +12-year Herman Miller warranty
  • +Good mesh breathability
  • +Mid-range pricing for Herman Miller
  • +Unique Y-Tower suspension design
Cons
  • -Coarse mesh irritates skin on legs
  • -Hard seat edges uncomfortable for larger users
  • -Seat too short - bottom slips out when reclining
  • -Lumbar support does not stay in place under pressure
  • -No headrest option
  • -Firm mesh seat
  • -Limited seat depth adjustment
  • -Basic lumbar (sacral support only)
Check on Amazon
Full Review
Check on Amazon
Full Review
Compare Different ChairsView All Rankings